Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Please note: Product availability and information are based on our research at time of writing and are subject to change. Always check Amazon for the latest details before purchasing. Reviews remain editorially independent.

Introduction

If the circulator on your heating system has died, or you’d rather swap an old one before it does, “which pump is best?” isn’t really the question. The one that matters is: which circulator fits my existing heating loop, and what should I check before ordering?

This guide compares five cast-iron circulators for closed-loop hot-water heating (baseboard, radiant or fan-coil zones) from Taco, Bell & Gossett and Armstrong. They aren’t interchangeable, and nobody can pick one for you without knowing how much flow and head your loop needs. We read each maker’s documents and checked the Amazon listings against them. We have not tested the pumps. Where a maker only prints a curve and no number, we read the chart and say so.

Looking for a pump to keep hot water coming to a faucet instead? That’s a different job. See our guides to hot-water recirculation pumps for homes with a dedicated return line and recirculation systems for homes without a return line.

✏️ Our Take

Match first, shop second. Read the label on your old pump for voltage and flange style, check whether you need a check valve, and know what flow and head your loop needs. In this group the Taco 007-F5 is the plain single-speed swap, the Taco 0015-MSF3-IFC and Armstrong Astro 230CI are three-speed pumps with a check valve built in, the B&G NRF-22 is a single-speed pump with a modest head, and the Taco 0015e3-2F4 is the low-power ECM option. None of that replaces sizing. If you can’t work out your loop’s flow and head, ask your installer.

IN THIS GUIDE

Before You Order: What to Check on Your Old Pump

Most of the work is done on the old pump’s label and the piping around it. Take a photo of the label before you shut anything off, then go through this list.

  • Voltage: all five run on single-phase 115 or 120 V, 60 Hz power.
  • Closed loop only: these are cast-iron pumps for closed hydronic heating. None of them is for drinking-water or open systems.
  • Flange and orientation: all five connect through flanges. The Taco 007 and 0015 sheets and B&G’s sheet list 3/4 to 1-1/2 in sizes. Several come in a standard and a rotated version, so check which one your old pump is. B&G lists companion flanges as a separate accessory, so check whether your old flanges and gaskets can be reused.
  • Check valve: the Taco 0015-MSF3-IFC and Armstrong Astro 230CI have one built in. The Taco 007-F5 and B&G NRF-22 sheets list none, so if your system needs a check valve, plan for one in the piping.
  • Flow and head: the pump has to suit what your loop needs, not just what the old pump was. Taco’s own replacement guide says flow rate and head-loss calculations should be done to choose the right circulator, so ask your installer if you can’t work it out.
  • Fluid: only Taco’s ECM sheet states a glycol limit (up to 50% water/glycol). The other sheets we read don’t, so if your loop uses antifreeze, check with the maker.
  • Controls: a single-speed pump just runs. A three-speed pump has a speed switch. The Taco 0015e3-2F4 has three constant-pressure settings. Make sure the pump’s controls suit how your system is wired and zoned.

Quick Comparison Table

Maximum flow and maximum head are separate maximums, not a single operating point. A pump can’t deliver both at once. Values with “about” are our readings of the maker’s printed curve, because that sheet gives no number.

Wide table: this table is wider than the page on small screens, so swipe or scroll it sideways to see every column →

Pump Control Max flow Max head Electrical Connection Buying link
Taco 007-F5 Single speed 23 gpm 10 ft 115 V, 0.74 A Flanged, standard orientation View on Amazon
Taco 0015-MSF3-IFC 3-speed; flow check built in 18 gpm 17 ft 115 V, 0.54 to 0.85 A Flanged, standard orientation View on Amazon
Bell & Gossett NRF-22 (103251) Single speed About 22 gpm About 15 ft 115 V, 0.80 A (92 W) Flanged; companion flanges listed as an accessory View on Amazon
Armstrong Astro 230CI (110223-305) 3-speed; removable check valve About 18 gpm About 19 ft 115 V, 0.45 to 0.81 A Flanged, two 1/2 in bolt holes View on Amazon
Taco 0015e3-2F4 ECM; three constant-pressure settings 16 gpm 18 ft (shut-off) 120 V, up to 44 W (0.54 A max) Universal flange View on Amazon

Where a figure is shown without “about,” it is printed on the maker’s sheet. The curves are linked in each review and in the Sources list.

Full Reviews: Five Circulators

The order below isn’t a ranking. Each review ends with what to check on the listing before you click.

1. Taco 007-F5

What Taco prints: single speed; up to 23 gpm of flow and up to 10 ft of head (two separate maximums); 115 V, 0.74 A, 1/25 hp, 3250 rpm; cast iron, flanged for 3/4 to 1-1/2 in pipe; 125 psi; 40 to 230 F. The pump’s own label, shown in the listing’s photos, reads 007-F5 and 230 F.

The 007 is Taco’s long-running cartridge circulator. Taco says the pump’s moving parts sit in a replaceable cartridge, so it can be serviced instead of replaced. The -F5 is the cast-iron version with Taco’s standard flange orientation. It runs at one speed and has no check valve built in; the flow-check models carry -IFC in the name.

You might consider it if you’re replacing a plain fixed-speed circulator on a small baseboard or radiant loop and want the simplest like-for-like swap, with no speed switch to set.

Advantages

  • Highest maximum flow of the five on paper: 23 gpm.
  • Single speed, with nothing to set or program.
  • Taco describes a replaceable cartridge design that can be serviced in place.
  • The listing bundles a set of two flange gaskets and a wire gland with the pump.

Limitations

  • Lowest maximum head of the five on paper: 10 ft. If your loop needs more head, look at the other four.
  • Fixed speed, so you can’t trim the output.
  • No built-in check valve in the sheets we read.
  • Taco’s sheet is from 2015, and it states no warranty term for this pump.

Before you click: this listing is a bundle: the 007-F5 pump plus two universal flange gaskets and a wire gland, according to the listing. Taco’s sheet describes the pump alone. The listing doesn’t say whether flanges are included, so check what you need. Taco also makes a rotated-flange version (007-F5-5), and this listing doesn’t state the orientation; the plain 007-F5 is Taco’s standard orientation. The curve is on page 2 of Taco’s 007 sheet, but it’s a chart shared with several 00-series pumps, so go by the printed 23 gpm and 10 ft.

Check on Amazon

2. Taco 0015-MSF3-IFC

What Taco prints: three-speed switch; up to 18 gpm of flow and up to 17 ft of head (two separate maximums); 115 V, 0.54, 0.74 and 0.85 A at speeds 1 to 3, 1/20 hp, 3250 rpm; cast iron, standard flange orientation, flanged for 3/4 to 1-1/2 in pipe; 125 psi; 40 to 230 F; removable integral flow check (IFC). The label in the listing’s photos reads 0015-MSF3-IFC.

Taco’s sheet describes the 0015 3-speed as a direct replacement for the Grundfos UPS 15-58 3-speed, which is worth knowing if that’s what you’re pulling out. The built-in flow check can save adding a separate check valve to the piping.

You might consider it if your loop needs more head than a 007-class pump, or you want to adjust speed to match the system, and you like having the check valve built in.

Advantages

  • Three speeds, so you can fine-tune the output.
  • Integral flow check, removable if you don’t need it.
  • 17 ft of maximum head, well above the 007-F5’s 10 ft.
  • Taco states it as a direct replacement for the Grundfos UPS 15-58 3-speed.

Limitations

  • The label’s power figures are 58, 79 and 98 W; Taco’s 0015e3 ECM sheet lists a 44 W maximum.
  • Standard flange orientation only; the rotated version is a separate model (0015-MSF3-1IFC).
  • Taco’s 2015 sheet states no warranty term for this model.
  • Taco’s sheet is from 2015.

Before you click: similar listings exist for the rotated version, the stainless version and the version without the flow check. This one says 0015-MSF3-IFC in the title and the model number. The curve is on Taco’s 3-speed sheet (page 1).

Check on Amazon

3. Bell & Gossett NRF-22 (103251)

What B&G prints: single speed; 92 W, 115 V, 0.80 A, 2940 rpm; cast iron body; 150 psi; 40 to 240 F; impedance-protected motor; companion flanges listed as available for 3/4 to 1-1/2 in pipe; 9.3 lb. B&G’s sheet prints a curve but no flow or head numbers. Reading it, the NRF-22 curve starts at about 15 ft of head and runs out at about 22 gpm (approximate).

B&G describes the NRF series as a flanged in-line circulator designed for quiet operation in a closed hydronic heating system. The NRF-22 is one of the single-speed models in the family; the three-speed pumps in the same sheet are the NRF-25, NRF-36 and NRF-45.

You might consider it if you’re replacing an NRF-22 or a similar small single-speed circulator and your loop is modest, so the pump’s smaller head suits it.

Advantages

  • B&G’s sheet rates it to 240 F and 150 psi.
  • B&G describes it for closed hydronic heating specifically.
  • Impedance-protected motor.
  • Simple single-speed design, like the 007-F5.

Limitations

  • Single speed.
  • No printed flow or head numbers, only a curve, so our figures are readings.
  • The heaviest of the five on the makers’ sheets at 9.3 lb.
  • B&G says the flange orientation varies, so check yours against the old pump.

Before you click: the title is “Bell & Gossett HVAC Circulator Pump 103251” and the model number field says 103251. The label in the listing’s photo reads “NRF-22 103251,” 115 V, .80 A, 92 W, 240 F. Other listings for 103251 call it a three-speed pump. B&G’s sheet lists the NRF-22 as single-speed, and this listing makes no speed claim. The curve is on page 2 of B&G’s submittal (single-speed chart).

Check on Amazon

4. Armstrong Astro 230CI (110223-305)

What Armstrong prints: three speeds; 115 V, 60 Hz; 0.45, 0.58 and 0.81 A at speeds 1 to 3 (nominal 97 W); cast iron for closed systems; removable check valve at the pump outlet; two-bolt flange with 1/2 in bolt holes; up to 230 F and 150 psi; ETL listed; 8.0 lb. The label in the listing’s photo reads Astro 230CI, part 110223-305. Armstrong’s submittal prints a curve, not flow and head numbers. Reading the speed-3 curve, it starts at about 19 ft of head and the plotted line runs to about 18 gpm (approximate).

Armstrong’s Astro 2 catalog says the line is built for flange-to-flange compatibility with competing models, and that the cast-iron volutes are e-coated on the inside. It also lists a 30-month warranty.

You might consider it if you want a three-speed circulator with a built-in check valve and a longer documented warranty than Taco’s sheets show, or you simply prefer Armstrong.

Advantages

  • Three speeds, with a removable check valve already installed.
  • Armstrong’s catalog lists a 30-month warranty.
  • Rated to 150 psi.
  • The sheet prints each speed’s amp draw.

Limitations

  • Curve only, so our flow and head figures are readings.
  • The warranty figure comes from Armstrong’s 2017 catalog; we didn’t find it on the 2021 submittal.
  • The listing’s Material field says stainless steel. Armstrong’s submittal lists the 230CI as cast iron, so check the title and label photo.

Before you click: choose 110223-305. The rotated-flange version is the 230CI-R (110223-315), and the stainless Astro 230SS is a different pump; Armstrong’s submittal lists the cast-iron models for closed systems and the stainless ones for open systems. The curve is on page 4 of Armstrong’s submittal.

Check on Amazon

5. Taco 0015e3-2F4

What Taco prints: ECM (electronically commutated) motor; three constant-pressure settings of 5, 10 and 18 ft; up to 16 gpm of flow and 18 ft of shut-off head (two separate maximums); 120 V, up to 44 W, 0.54 A maximum; cast-iron casing for closed-loop systems only; 125 psi; 36 to 230 F; water or up to 50% water/glycol; indoor use only. The 2F4 is the cast-iron model with Taco’s universal flange. The listing’s model number field says 0015e3-2F4.

Taco says the 0015e3’s performance is equivalent to its 0015 3-speed circulator. Its heating selection guide pairs the settings with the longest circuit in the system: low for 85 ft of 3/4 in copper, medium for 165 ft, high for 245 ft.

You might consider it if you want a low-power ECM pump and your system is zoned with zone valves or circulators. Whether it can replace your current pump depends on four things: the flow and head your loop needs, the voltage (this pump is 120 V), the flange (universal here) and the controls.

Advantages

  • Up to 44 W, against 98 W at the 0015-MSF3-IFC label’s top speed.
  • Three constant-pressure settings, with a selection guide by circuit length.
  • Taco states a glycol limit of 50%.
  • Universal flange.

Limitations

  • Maximum flow is 16 gpm, below the 007-F5’s 23 gpm.
  • Cast iron is closed loop only.
  • Taco’s August 2021 version of this sheet states a three-year limited warranty from the date code; the 2023 sheet we read doesn’t repeat it.
  • The three settings are fixed constant-pressure steps (5, 10 or 18 ft), so confirm one of them suits your loop.

Before you click: make sure the page shows 0015e3-2F4. The 0015e3-2F2 has a standard flange, and the SF4 and SU models are stainless steel. The curve and settings are on page 2 of Taco’s 0015e3 sheet.

Check on Amazon

Three-Speed Side by Side: Taco 0015-MSF3-IFC vs Armstrong Astro 230CI

These two are close cousins. Both are cast iron, both run on 115 V, both have three speeds and a removable check valve. Here’s where the documents show a difference.

Wide table: this table is wider than the page on small screens, so swipe or scroll it sideways to see every column →

  Taco 0015-MSF3-IFC Armstrong Astro 230CI
Speeds 3 3
Max flow / max head 18 gpm / 17 ft (printed) About 18 gpm / about 19 ft (chart reading)
Electrical 115 V; 0.54, 0.74, 0.85 A 115 V; 0.45, 0.58, 0.81 A
Check valve Integral flow check, removable Removable check valve at the pump outlet
Flange fit Standard orientation; the rotated version is the 0015-MSF3-1IFC The rotated version is the 230CI-R (110223-315); two 1/2 in bolt holes
Warranty as documented None stated on the 2015 sheet we read 30 months (2017 Astro 2 catalog)
Limits 125 psi; 40 to 230 F 150 psi; up to 230 F
Weight on the maker’s sheet 8 lb (ship weight) 8.0 lb

What it comes down to: if you’re matching an existing pump’s flange, the real question is whether your old pump has a standard or rotated flange. Each maker has a standard and a rotated model, so you have to pick the right one in either brand. On the check valve, both makers describe one that can be removed; Taco calls its design an integral flow check, and Armstrong’s sheet says a removable check valve is installed at the pump outlet. Neither document gives enough detail to separate them. The clearer difference is warranty: Armstrong’s catalog lists 30 months, and the Taco sheet we read lists none. The head figures differ too, but Taco’s is a printed number and Armstrong’s is our chart reading, so treat them as roughly similar.

How to Choose

Start with the old pump

If you’re swapping like for like, the old pump’s label tells you most of what you need: voltage, size, and sometimes the model. Match the voltage and the flange first. Then decide whether you want the same speed behavior or an upgrade.

Fixed speed, three-speed or ECM

A fixed-speed pump (the 007-F5 and NRF-22) is the simplest: it runs at one speed. A three-speed pump (the Taco 0015-MSF3-IFC and Armstrong Astro 230CI) lets you pick a speed to fit the loop. An ECM pump (the Taco 0015e3-2F4) is built to use less power. Its three settings hold a constant pressure, so check how that fits your zones.

Don’t guess the size

The maximum flow and head on a sheet are limits, not what you’ll get in your system. Flow and head together decide what a pump will do in a particular loop, which is why Taco’s guide says to run the calculations. If you can’t, your installer can.

Installation

The instructions packed with your exact pump come first, and what’s here is general. Circulators involve electrical power, hot water and pressurized piping, so if you aren’t comfortable draining the system and wiring the pump, hire a qualified installer.

Need a Professional Plumber?

Sometimes a job is too big for DIY. To find local plumbers, you can search PlumberArchive.com, a plumber directory.

Search PlumberArchive.com →

How We Researched This

We started from the maker’s own documents for each exact model: Taco’s catalog and submittal sheets, the Bell & Gossett submittal, and the Armstrong submittal and catalog. Where we couldn’t open the maker’s own site, we relied on a distributor’s copy of the same document and label it as a hosted copy in the Sources list. For each pump we then opened the Amazon listing and checked that its title, model number and, where the listing’s photos show one, the label match the maker’s model. Our affiliate links were each opened and confirmed to land on that same listing.

We have not tested these pumps. The sheets are different ages, and some are several years old, so confirm current details with the maker or your installer. Figures labelled “about” are our readings of a printed curve. Buying advice here is general: it isn’t a sizing calculation for your system.

Sources

Documents and listings read on 12 November 2026. Each document is listed with its date or revision. A “hosted copy” is a distributor’s or retailer’s copy of the maker’s document.

  • Taco Catalog 100-1.8 and submittal 101-029, Model 007 Cartridge Circulator (effective 06/10/15), hosted copy: Taco 007 sheet. The curve is on page 2.
  • Taco submittal 101-125, 3-Speed Cartridge Circulators (effective 06/26/15), hosted copy: Taco 0015 3-speed sheet. The curve is on page 1.
  • Taco submittal 101-201, 0015e3 ECM High-Efficiency Circulator (effective 1 February 2023 per the sheet), hosted copy: Taco 0015e3 sheet. The settings chart is on page 2.
  • Taco Circulator Replacement Guide (undated), hosted copy: Taco guide.
  • Bell & Gossett submittal A-126F, System Lubricated Iron Body Circulators, Model NRF (© 2007), hosted copy: B&G submittal. A 2026 Xylem copy with the same NRF-22 line is also available.
  • Armstrong Astro 2 Three Speed Circulators submittal, file 10.584 (1 July 2021), hosted copy: Armstrong submittal. Curves are on page 4.
  • Armstrong Astro 2 catalog, file 10.125 (October 2017), hosted copy: Armstrong catalog.

✍️ About This Review

PTR Editorial Team — Product Reviews. We compare manufacturer specifications, installation requirements, compatibility and available product documentation to help homeowners choose suitable tools and parts. How we review →